Fatty and Mabel's Simple Life

Fatty and Mabel's Simple Life (1915)

* 1/2 (out of 4)

Fatty Arbuckle and Mabel Normand wish to be married but her father promises her to another man so the two must try and find a way to run off. I gave these Fatty shirts a break last year after not really enjoying them and that trend continues this year. I'm not sure what it is but Fatty just isn't working with me and he's certainly not making me laugh. The film is just so dry that nothing really works, although there's a wonderful physical gag at the end.

Fatty's New Role (1915)

*** (out of 4)

A hobo (Fatty Arbuckle) is kicked out of a bar but the guests there decide to play a joke on the owner by saying the hobo was the notorious bomber who bombs the places he's thrown out of. This here manages to be quite funny thanks to the performances of the supporting cast who really sell the joke.

This Fatty Arbuckle-Mabel Normand finds the two of them down on the farm where her dad doesn't approve of his daughter's interest in a guy with no future. He's got plans for her to marry the son of the richest man in the county who coincidentally enough has the mortgage on the property.

I nearly blew my mind when I saw the handsome, but shallow suitor was Al St. John who later became a comic sidekick in hundreds of B westerns. He also was Fatty Arbuckle's nephew.

Arbuckle and Normand are a pretty funny pair and that last scene with them fleeing in a car to get over the state line so they can marry is pretty hilarious. Remember what cars were back in those days, rather tricky things and Fatty's Flivver seems to have a mind of its own.

Ironic indeed that both Arbuckle and Normand were involved in two of the biggest scandals and earliest ones in film history and both came to a premature end. Still they are funny pair to enjoy and appreciate today.

This is a very enjoyable feature starring Roscoe Arbuckle and Mabel Normand, and its carefree slapstick style does not obscure a pretty good job of direction by Arbuckle himself. The story successfully blends some familiar elements with a couple of creative ideas, and the pacing works well, starting with an easygoing tempo and gradually building to a hilariously manic pace.

It starts with a setup that was also used in several of Arbuckle's other earlier movies, with Normand as the farmer's daughter who is in love with hired hand Roscoe, and Al St. John as the rich rival preferred by Normand's father. The first half features lots of light slapstick in the farm and farmhouse. Most of it of good quality, and it also builds up sympathy for the two main characters.

This sets up the extended chase in the second half, which is very funny and which packs a lot of good slapstick gags into a reel or so of film. Things move at breakneck speed, yet at no time does it seem out of control or pointless. It's an example of the Keystone style working at its best, with a free-wheeling feel that nevertheless must have involved good planning. The gags with the driver-less car and with the well squeeze an impressive amount of mileage out of a couple of simple ideas.

For fans of silent comedy, almost anything with Arbuckle and Normand has considerable appeal. But this is one of their most enjoyable features together.

Having spent months watching all the shorts with Buster Keaton and being absolutely charmed by Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle's direction, timing and "delivery", as well as regularly laughing out loud, I was so excited to see something earlier. And, wow... this was flat, boring and exactly what most people think silent movies will be: people literally jumping around, doing pratfalls and slapstick, literally kicking each other in the butt, and mugging for the camera. It's like they set up a camera and said, "Go try to do something that looks funny and we'll film it." The rampaging car was just... dumb. What a disappointment. Jump ahead to the later stuff, it's SO much better and really shows Arbuckle's charm and talents and creativity.

Fatty is a farmhand on the farm owned by Mabel's father. Their neighbor holds their mortgage and indicated in a letter that he would no longer collect rent IF Mabel were to marry his son (Al St. John). In many ways, this film is very reminiscent of another Arbuckle short, MABEL AND FATTY ADRIFT, as this also features Fatty working on the farm owned by Mabel's parents AND the neighbor, Al St. John wants to marry her. BUT, in MABEL AND FATTY'S SIMPLE LIFE, Mabel's father does want St. John to marry his daughter and what happens from there is very different. In fact, they are different enough that both films can be enjoyed, though MABLE AND FATTY ADRIFT is perhaps one of Arbuckle's greatest films, whereas this one is about average for the star (which is STILL good).

As Mabel's selfish Dad is trying to sell her off, she elopes with Fatty and there is a prolonged chase. Cute stuff worth seeing.