Ever since his big screen debut in Joel Schumacher's 'Tigerland,' Shea Whigham has been a compelling force. Consistently reliable, he has delivered nuanced performances in everything, from Goran Dukic's 'Wristcutters: A Love Story' to the TV shows 'Boardwalk Empire' and 'Gaslit'. Ever versatile and understated, Whigham brings a captivating authenticity to his roles, always seeming perfectly cast.
That proves to be the case once more in Jeffrey Reiner's 'Lake George.' A comic crime drama, it follows Don, an ex-con. In debt to a gangster, he is hired to kill Phyllis, an ex-employee of the thug. Don reluctantly takes the job, though the savvy Phyllis proves to be more than she seems. She and Don team up, and as they navigate the sun-drenched streets of California, they dodge danger, scheming their way through tricky situations, as they develop an unexpected bond.
Akin to a Coen Brother film or an Elmore Leonard adaptation, it's a fantastic neo-noir, brimming with dark comedy. The narrative unfolds with a blend of wit and grit, with a careful balance of tension and humour. As Don and Phyllis hit the road, one is treated to a taut caper, full of strong dialogue and engaging moments. Reiner's characterisation is deft; every personality is well-rounded. Tense and darkly funny, the film is compelling from start to finish.
Moreover, beneath the surface lies a poignant exploration of redemption and human connection. Don and Phyllis, despite their criminal inclinations, find themselves reflecting on their pasts and questioning their futures in a world that's seemingly set against them. It's this emotional depth, woven seamlessly into the narrative, that elevates the film beyond its premise.
Reiner avoids the usual tropes found in films like this, subverting our expectations. Don is a sensitive soul, who wants nothing more than to get to the eponymous lake and rest. He isn't a stoic gunman, walking with steely determination like Lee Marvin in 'Point Blank.' He's an uncertain chap, struggling with an existential crisis- not exactly your usual main character in a neo-noir. He's a refreshingly atypical protagonist, who is hard not to root for.
In addition, Phyllis isn't just your usual smart-mouthed moll going along for the ride. She's clever, witty and resilient and will do whatever it takes to survive. Her relationship with Don is complex and layered, evolving from mere convenience to a genuine bond forged by their shared struggles. This evolving dynamic adds an emotional resonance, making their journey not just a thrilling romp, but also an exploration of trust and redemption.
One minor drawback is the third act, which feels slightly rote. As the narrative edges toward its conclusion, the film leans on familiar neo-noir beats, such as a predictable final confrontation, that is less inventive and unexpected than previous acts. However, even as it trades some of its earlier unpredictability for convention, the characters' arcs still land with a satisfying resonance, making the climax a powerful moment.
Furthermore, Tod Campbell's vibrant cinematography is striking, enhancing the film's tone and atmosphere. From the busy streets of L. A. to the serene landscapes approaching Lake George, every shot is meticulously crafted. Campbell captures the contrast between the chaos of urban life and the calm, almost dream-like quality of the destination Don yearns for. This visual storytelling not only enriches the narrative but also adds depth.
In addition, Stuart Blatt's production design heightens the film's immersive effect and noiresque qualities. Moreover, Rene G. Boscio's evocative score complements the visual storytelling, underscoring the tension and humour throughout. Brian Beal's editing is also a key factor, establishing a steady pace that never lets up.
Having said that, the film could have easily failed were it not for its two stars, Shea Whigham and Carrie Coon. Whigham delivers a layered performance, showcasing a man torn between his past and his desire for a peaceful future. He makes the fragile Don a compelling character, imbuing him with a sense of vulnerability that is both touching and relatable. Grounded and believable, Whigham is terrific.
Coon is similarly good, blending sharp intelligence with resilience and depth. Her Phyllis is not one to be fooled, and Coon brings a fierce determination to the role that is captivating to watch. She masterfully balances Phyllis's toughness with moments of vulnerability, creating a complex and multi-dimensional character. Her and Whigham's palpable chemistry ensures the film is a smooth ride from start to finish. Meanwhile, all in the supporting cast- particularly Max Castella as one of the gangster's henchmen- deliver strong performances.
With 'Lake George,' Jeffrey Reiner has made a gripping, darkly funny crime flick that is sure to please. Boasting striking cinematography and a stirring score, it works on multiple levels. Reiner reworks the archetypes of noir storytelling- offering a 'hitman and moll' dynamic that defies cliché. His narrative is engaging and the characters within compelling. Stars Shea Whigham and Carrie Coon are both brilliant, while their supporting cast don't let them down. In short, the clever crime caper 'Lake George' makes waves and sails smoothly.
