User reviews

I saw the Mrs Maisel pilot on a plane (no pun intended) and I was very impressed by the quality of the production and of course the storyline of Mrs Maisel who wants to make it big in comedy.

Can Mrs Maisel survive the rough and tumble of stand-up comedy in New York City of all places?

It didn't take long for Amazon Prime Video to make a splash with some very successful outings out the bat. However, it's probably biggest success came in the form of a comedy show, created by "Gilmore Girls" creator Amy Sherman-Palladino, that told the story of a housewife who learns of her talents at stand-up comedy. The show was not a guaranteed success though, and Amazon didn't even pick it up until after the pilot had been released to a lot of buzz and critical acclaim. And the pilot of "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel" is a dazzling and triumphant introduction to a very promising comedy series.

From the first scene, the writing captivates with its razor-sharp wit, expertly blending laugh-out-loud humor with incisive social commentary. The show's exploration of gender identity in the 1950s, particularly through the lens of the male-dominated comedy industry, feels both fresh and fearless. The dialogue moves at a breakneck pace, filled with zany one-liners and clever banter, while also highlighting the absurd societal constraints placed on women, making the humor deeply resonant. Visually, the show transports viewers back to the glamorous 1950s with an impeccable sense of style. The direction and production design captures the era in stunning detail, from the vibrant costumes to the bustling streets of New York, creating a world that feels both nostalgic and alive. The music selection is pitch-perfect, with its lively jazz tunes and vintage soundtracks adding energy and authenticity to every scene. The overall aesthetic makes the show a visual delight, a bright and bold homage to mid-century New York. At the center of it all is Rachel Brosnahan, who delivers a standout, dynamic performance as Midge Maisel. Brosnahan seamlessly shifts from the polished, picture-perfect housewife to a woman discovering her comedic voice, particularly in the episode's exhilarating climatic moment - her impromptu, unfiltered stand-up routine. In this scene, Brosnahan's magnetic presence and flawless timing shine, marking Midge's breakthrough not only as a comedian but as a woman claiming her own identity. It's a scene brimming with raw energy, humor, and emotional truth, and it promises that Midge's journey will be a thrilling one to watch unfold across the show.

The pilot makes "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel" promise not only to entertain with its humor and aesthetic brilliance but also to deliver a thoughtful, layered exploration of women challenging societal norms. It's an absolute triumph - a must-watch for fans of sharp writing, strong performances, and bold storytelling.