A Farewell to Arms

Obviously, a great deal of time and money was lavished on this project. Producer Selznick intended it to be a vindication of a career that peaked with "Gone With The Wind" in 1939, and then began a long, slow, almost painful decline. By the mid fifties he had become something of a "has-been" in Hollywood. The result? Pretty much a miss. The book is probably unfilmable, of course, but the screenplay still leaves much to be desired. Rock Hudson is far too shallow to make a go at the over-the-top emotionalism this story needs. The usually wonderful Jennifer Jones, for whom this project was conceived, somehow doesn't seem to exhibit the idealism and resolve the part needs, and that she demonstrated with such seemingly effortlessness in many other films. The direction is stilted and sometimes downright awkward, more the fault of producer Selznick, I would bet, who had a reputation for micro-managing his films, than famed director Charles Vidor.

Simply put, I'm never convinced, not even for a moment, that what is happening is real and not just another movie. Too bad.

Recently read the book...disappointed by the movie as it departed from the story in several key areas. The scenery was pretty.

Rock Hudson wasn't bad but it was painfully obvious that Jennifer Jones was a lot older than him. It was absurd she was supposed to be English when she sounded just as American as Hudson and Elaine Stritch. The film is spectacular but too overblown for a trifling romantic story.

There are so many things that are wrong here - not just the fact that Jennifer Jones was too old to play this part in husband Selznick's movie. First, the script. At times, it is very good, while at others it is amateurish and downright silly. You cringe as the actors say some of their embarrassing bad dialogue. Second, the production values are just as inconsistent. Sometimes, the film looks cheap and like it was made on a dime (for example, it's got some of the worst painted backdrops ever filmed - so obviously fake). But, when it is filmed in actual Italian locales, it looks terrific. Third, the acting by the Jones and Hudson is irritating. They really ham it up so much that it must be seen to be believed. In the more lighthearted segments they are sickeningly sweet and sentimental, while in the dramatic parts, they are so overwrought or serious that you just want to slap them into sensibility. The supporting cast is excellent : Vittorio DeSica (who even managed to get nominated for an Oscar for his performance here), the always interesting Mercedes McCambridge, Oskar Homolka, Kurt Kaszner, and the wonderful Elaine Stritch, who someone had the great sense to cast in her role as a sympathetic nurse. The problem is, the two big hams (Jones and Hudson) keep getting in their way, distracting from their fine performances. Maybe that's why DeSica got his nomination - the Academy felt sorry for him. I've read that the filming of this was beset by many problems caused by producer Selznick, who kept firing staff and replacing them. To many cooks spoil the soup - and that old adage is proven here. The result : an embarrassing critical and box office failure.

Selznick never made another movie.

Jones wouldn't make another movie for 5 years.

And Hudson's career was in the dumper until he made a big comeback in those Doris Day movies.

All in all, watch this if you want to be entertained by some jaw-dropping ineptitude. It's kind of amazing.

Strange that one of America's favorite writers has no success in having his novels transferred to the screen with any fidelity or improvement over the original. 'A Farewell to Arms' is a lumbering, turgid, over-stuffed movie that never seems real. Chemistry between Hudson and Jones is simply not there--Jennifer Jones, in particular, seems remote and detached as the nurse even when she's supposed to be wildly in love. And then there's the matter of length--it seems to go on forever with a very weak resolution.

David O. Selznick wanted to create something that would rank alongside his 'Gone with the Wind' as an epic romance with a war background--but the talky script defeated everyone. Hemingway himself publicly disowned the movie, claiming that Jones was far too old for the part and unhappy about the film in general. At any rate, it was not the hoped for success and did nothing to halt the decline of Selznick's career--or Jennifer Jones' career for that matter. A big disappointment.