Aneel Kanneganti's 2023 Telugu thriller Hidimbha attempts to deliver a unique blend of serial killer investigation and elements of tribal horror, delving into themes of cannibalism and ancient lineage. Starring Ashwin Babu and Nandita Swetha as the lead police officers, Abhay and Aadhya, the film sets out to unravel the mystery behind a series of missing girls in Hyderabad, all of whom share a disturbing commonality: they were wearing red dresses.
The film's initial premise is intriguing, promising a dark and mysterious ride. The disappearances of girls, the involvement of a special officer, and the hint of something far more sinister than a typical serial killer create an air of suspense. The narrative aims to build tension as the police force struggles to piece together the clues, eventually leading them to a remote, tribal context and the titular "Hidimbha" clan. This shift from an urban crime thriller to a more primal, almost mythological horror element is where the film tries to differentiate itself.
However, Hidimbha's ambition often outstrips its execution. While the concept of an aboriginal clan with cannibalistic tendencies is certainly novel for Telugu cinema, the screenplay struggles to fully integrate these disparate elements. The first half of the film, focusing on the police investigation, often feels conventional and at times, suffers from a lack of genuine thrills or compelling character development for its leads. The relationship between Abhay and Aadhya, former lovers, feels underdeveloped and doesn't add much emotional weight to the escalating crisis.
The film truly leans into its unique premise in the second half, particularly during the flashback sequences that delve into the history and practices of the Hidimbha tribe. These portions, while visually engaging and offering some of the film's more gruesome moments, also highlight the narrative's struggle with logical coherence. The abrupt shifts in tone and the reliance on twists, some of which are not entirely unpredictable, can leave the audience feeling disoriented rather than genuinely shocked.
A major point of contention in critical reception has been the film's handling of its central twist - the revelation of the true antagonist. While designed to be a shocking reveal, it often raises more questions than it answers, undermining some of the earlier established plotlines and character motivations. The film attempts to connect the modern-day crimes with ancient practices and personal vendettas, but the bridge between these two timelines often feels tenuous and forced.
Performances in Hidimbha are a mixed bag. Ashwin Babu, in an action-heavy role, shows physical commitment but at times struggles with the emotional depth required for his character. Nandita Swetha, as Aadhya, is given a more substantial role and tries to ground the film with her earnest performance, but even her efforts can't fully overcome the script's inconsistencies. Makarand Deshpande, in a key negative role, stands out, delivering a menacing presence that adds much-needed intensity.
Ultimately, Hidimbha is a film with a genuinely interesting concept that unfortunately falters in its execution. It attempts to weave together a complex tapestry of crime, mythology, and horror, but the threads often unravel due to a disjointed screenplay, logical loopholes, and an uneven pace. While it offers a few engaging moments and some genuinely unsettling visuals, particularly in its more gruesome sequences, it ultimately falls short of its ambitious potential, leaving viewers with a sense of a daring attempt that didn't quite hit its mark.
