Why these imports are not grouped? #2221

failable · 2024-01-05T07:44:08Z

failable
Jan 5, 2024

Command: isort --profile b.py
Before b.py:

from a import Conversation as APIConversation
from a import (
    AnalysisRequest,
    AnalysisResponse,
    CryptoWikiRequest,
    CryptoWikiResponse,
    DispatchRequest,
    DispatchResponse,
    ExtractRequest,
    ExtractResponse,
    FallbackRequest,
    FallbackStreamResponse,
    SqlAssistantRequest,
    SqlAssistantResponse,
    GoogleSearchRequest,
    GoogleSearchStreamResponse,
    LinkingRequest,
    LinkingResponse,
    MoneyFlowRequest,
    MoneyFlowResponse,
    NewsAggregatorRequest,
    NewsAggregatorResponse,
    NewsHeadlinesRequest,
    NewsHeadlinesResponse,
    NewsRAGRequest,
    NewsRAGResponse,
    OOOO,
    PriceInfoRequest,
    PriceInfoStreamResponse,
    QuestionRequest,
    QuestionResponse,
    RAGRequest,
    RAGStreamResponse,
    RephraseRequest,
    RephraseResponse,
    SimilarityDispatchRequest,
    StreamResponse,
    TechnicalAnalystRequest,
    TechnicalAnalystStreamResponse,
    WalletProfileRequest,
    WalletProfileResponse,
    ZZZZ,
)

After b.py.

from a import OOOO, ZZZZ, AnalysisRequest, AnalysisResponse
from a import Conversation as APIConversation
from a import (
    CryptoWikiRequest,
    CryptoWikiResponse,
    DispatchRequest,
    DispatchResponse,
    ExtractRequest,
    ExtractResponse,
    FallbackRequest,
    FallbackStreamResponse,
    GoogleSearchRequest,
    GoogleSearchStreamResponse,
    LinkingRequest,
    LinkingResponse,
    MoneyFlowRequest,
    MoneyFlowResponse,
    NewsAggregatorRequest,
    NewsAggregatorResponse,
    NewsHeadlinesRequest,
    NewsHeadlinesResponse,
    NewsRAGRequest,
    NewsRAGResponse,
    PriceInfoRequest,
    PriceInfoStreamResponse,
    QuestionRequest,
    QuestionResponse,
    RAGRequest,
    RAGStreamResponse,
    RephraseRequest,
    RephraseResponse,
    SimilarityDispatchRequest,
    SqlAssistantRequest,
    SqlAssistantResponse,
    StreamResponse,
    TechnicalAnalystRequest,
    TechnicalAnalystStreamResponse,
    WalletProfileRequest,
    WalletProfileResponse,
)

a.py

class AnalysisRequest:
    pass


class AnalysisResponse:
    pass


class CryptoWikiRequest:
    pass


class CryptoWikiResponse:
    pass


class DispatchRequest:
    pass


class DispatchResponse:
    pass


class ExtractRequest:
    pass


class ExtractResponse:
    pass


class FallbackRequest:
    pass


class FallbackStreamResponse:
    pass


class SqlAssistantRequest:
    pass


class SqlAssistantResponse:
    pass


class GoogleSearchRequest:
    pass


class GoogleSearchStreamResponse:
    pass


class LinkingRequest:
    pass


class LinkingResponse:
    pass


class MoneyFlowRequest:
    pass


class MoneyFlowResponse:
    pass


class NewsAggregatorRequest:
    pass


class NewsAggregatorResponse:
    pass


class NewsHeadlinesRequest:
    pass


class NewsHeadlinesResponse:
    pass


class NewsRAGRequest:
    pass


class NewsRAGResponse:
    pass


class PriceInfoRequest:
    pass


class PriceInfoStreamResponse:
    pass


class QuestionRequest:
    pass


class QuestionResponse:
    pass


class RAGRequest:
    pass


class RAGStreamResponse:
    pass


class RephraseRequest:
    pass


class RephraseResponse:
    pass


class SimilarityDispatchRequest:
    pass


class StreamResponse:
    pass


class TechnicalAnalystRequest:
    pass


class TechnicalAnalystStreamResponse:
    pass


class WalletProfileRequest:
    pass


class WalletProfileResponse:
    pass


class Conversation:
    pass


class ZZZZ:
    pass


class OOOO:
    pass

guillermodotn · 2025-04-05T19:04:11Z

guillermodotn
Apr 5, 2025

As all your imports are from the same module a.py, isort is sorting them alphabetically, with precedence given to capital letters. By default, isort also separates aliased imports (as) from regular ones. That’s why you're seeing three distinct import blocks:

Imports that come before Conversation alphabetically.
The import with an alias: Conversation as APIConversation.
Imports that come after Conversation alphabetically.

If you want to group them all into a single block, you can set:

combine_as_imports = true

in your isort configuration.

Also, the command you're using appears to be incorrect, make sure to define the profile isort should use (e.g., --profile black). You can find more details in the isort documentation.

Hope this will help you.

0 replies

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Why these imports are not grouped? #2221

Uh oh!

{{title}}

Uh oh!

Replies: 1 comment

Uh oh!

{{title}}

Uh oh!

Select a reply

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Why these imports are not grouped? #2221

Uh oh!

failable Jan 5, 2024

Replies: 1 comment

Uh oh!

guillermodotn Apr 5, 2025

failable
Jan 5, 2024

guillermodotn
Apr 5, 2025